10 things to do this summer
snippets of joy
THE JOYFUL REMAKING OF EDUCATION
dear jackie
stories of joy
Issue #14
the joy of leadership
future of education: scholarship
feature poem and articles
wellbeing crossword
joyfe
think piece: intersectionality
welcome to Joyfe #14
And breathe…………….. Welcome to the summer break edition of the JoyFE Magazine. We truly hope that you are well and are about to, or are having, some down time, after what has been a relentless academic year. Now is the time to really carve out some space to recharge, to recover, to reflect on the year, but more importantly ask yourself the question ‘How are you?’. There has been change after change, and update after update, and before we knew it, we have been planning for the new academic year without a breath. The word reflection has been used many times, so it would be interesting if organisations, teams or individuals have managed to sit and think deeply about the journey so far and what we have learned. I recently listened to Brene Brown talking to Charles Duhigg on her Dare to Lead podcast about productivity and one of the keys being the practice of thinking more deeply about what we are doing and how we are doing it. It’s hard to build in a practice of thinking when everything is deemed urgent or the to do list is really long. Maybe if we are going to take something into next year, it’s the intention to create more spaces to think. Maybe it will save us time in the long run, maybe it will support us to become more efficient and effective. The podcast also implies that emails should never have been a mechanism by which we communicate and I say ‘Amen’ to that! We have an autopilot mode, which has no doubt been in play for most of the year and so it can be hard to change gear, but it is in the down time we can start to notice how we really are. What are the things that light us up? Where do we carve out the time to switch off? Digitally detox? Be outside? Be on our own? Nurture the relationships that are important to us? In this edition, we bring you our usual features and articles, written by people from across the sector. We hope you take the time to rest and reflect, using some of the features to prompt your thinking. We are forever grateful for your support and we encourage you to share the magazine with the people who may find it useful or those who are not on edusocialmedia. Keep in touch with us over summer on Twitter @JoyfulFE to share your moments of summer joy. Much Love Stef @Stef_Wilkinson
2
4
wellbeing 7
7
6
14
13
an interview with... deborah mcvey
22
16
in this issue
10
28
3
book review
11
future of education
8
Compiled by Heather Booth martin
As a trainee teacher in FE what brings me joy is that everyday I am learning something new that can help me bloom, develop and progress as a teacher on a daily basis. I am teaching a subject which I am incredibly passionate about that I have experience in. I really enjoy that I am part of helping and supporting the students on their path of education and preparing them for what they do in later life. I want to change students’ views on education and I hope I inspire and motivate them with engaging and interesting lessons. This job is so rewarding when students are able to use the subject knowledge you have taught them in their work and placement.
Stephanie Cowling
Erin Marshall
The feeling of happiness starts on the walk up to the classroom. I am teaching a subject I have been passionate about since I was in primary school. I wonder about the new things students will share with me. Every lesson I view maths through others’ eyes and try to untangle their misconceptions in a way that makes sense to them - this to me is both challenging and fulfilling. The satisfaction you feel when their view changes and they are able to see maths differently, even if just for that lesson, is what drives me every day.
Salma Younis
STORIES OF JOY...
As a new teacher in FE I have had many moments that have brought me joy, even with my first year of teaching being in the midst of the pandemic. I loved seeing classes bond with each other even though they are learning online. Seeing students adapt so well to returning to college after months at home, shows how incredible the young people I teach are. One thing that will stay with me throughout my career in education is when a student said to me “I understand now, I never really took things in at school but I get it now.” That filled me with so much joy and reminded me why I chose to become a teacher in FE!
by daniel scott @_daniel_scott
What do we mean by vulnerability? In the last twelve months vulnerability as a leadership approach has increased in popularity. There’s often a deep-rooted culture in organisations that we shouldn’t reveal our tender areas; what we truly don't know, where we need support. Forcing a culture where we mask our vulnerabilities in an effort to conceal true needs blocks the resources we can offer others and the organisation. Brené Brown (2018) defines vulnerability as; “…the emotion we experience during times of uncertainty, risk and emotional exposure” (p 19). It’s true that humans are emotional beings and the workplace is often an emotional experience. Therefore we are hindering the emergence of our natural emotional intelligence – hiding the essence of our humanity. “To feel is to be vulnerable. Believing that vulnerability is weakness is believing that feeling is weakness.” (p 42) Revealing vulnerability is not just a matter of encouragement or coercion. It takes time through a gradual and careful process of enabling open, trusting and nurturing environments, supported by inspiring values. Perhaps some people find it uncomfortable to be vulnerable, and organisational culture may be to blame. However, we can support each other to embed this approach in our professionalism. Yes there's the blurriness of conforming to standards but we mustn't shy away from braving courage and speaking about our weaker areas, after all we work in learning and development. If we can easily express our terms we have little reason not to express our vulnerabilities. Being open with colleagues can help us individually and develop stronger collaborative working relationships with peers, moving from transactional to relational. All while defeating imposter syndrome-provoking environments. “Leaders must either invest a reasonable amount of time attending to fears and feelings, or squander an unreasonable amount of time trying to manage ineffective and unproductive behaviour.” (p 70). A little story. After being inspired by Brown’s vulnerabilities work (p 98), I injected a question around weaknesses in our team meeting. I’ll never forget one introverted individual who embraced the question and stated that they fear rejection. Now that was powerful for me to hear and explained so much about that person’s needs and how they could be nurtured. Personally, it empowered me to be more inclusive when collaborating with that person. It later led to a team approach to uncover our strengths and to begin to move beyond our individual silos. This is what I was trying to achieve: “…Instead of a ten-person race, we start to develop a coordinated relay in which team members baton-toss to each other’s strengths instead of vying to run the whole stretch alone. Once everyone understands their value, we stop hustling for worthiness and lean into our gifts.” (p 98). How can we progress embedding a vulnerability-embracing culture? Brown (2018) asserts that if an organisation’s success metric: “…depends on creativity and innovation and you set up a culture where vulnerability is seen as weakness. Don’t expect great results.” (60 Minutes, 2020) Educational establishments fall into this category. I recommend we start to bring vulnerability into a real conversation to further establish what we mean by it as a department/team and begin to develop pragmatic solutions. Some questions to consider: What problems or issues does this approach address? What does it mean to be vulnerable and authentic? Why should we be communicating our vulnerabilities and what are the benefits? How can we demystify assumptions that categorise vulnerabilities as unnecessary oversharing or self-disclosure? How can we nurture a culture that embraces vulnerability dialogue? Pragmatically, perhaps we can explore the following: Model in our own leadership and management practices Model application through identified organisational principles, values, missions etc Explore how this supports and shapes operational formats Apply and test the principles and practices of one of the four courage skill sets: ‘rumbling with vulnerability’ – part one of Dare to Lead book or the Read-Along-Workbook Create Thinking Environments as a way to refine our thoughts to this paper Over to you What thoughts and views come to mind? Do you agree or disagree with any of this? Should we proceed in taking any action? If so, would any of these initial suggestions make good starting points for a conversation.
Bringing vulnerability into practice
Click here for Daniel's blog and the full references
Coming soon…. Joyful Education offerings on innovative supportive cultures. For now come and join us in the IdeasRoom on Wednesdays at 8pm to see some of the principles of innovation in action.
5
Thinkpiece : iNTERSECTIONALITY
By DR lOU MYCroFT @LOUMYCROFT
The word ‘intersectionality’ is where identities meet at a junction, it's the British English word for crossroads. As Audre Lorde famously said, “There is no such thing as a single issue, because we do not live single issue lives.” In FE, we tend to focus on single identity interventions, at the expense of intersectionality. By the time you read this, the Euro2020 football competition will be a fading memory; we’ll be into the Olympics. But I’m writing this the morning after the night before, when the chasm between diverse Britain and its haters seems ever wider. In FE, we have the immense privilege of reaching into those communities where people have least, in particular the lives of 16-18 year olds, and where identities intersect across the nine protected characteristics of the Equality Act 2010 and then some. FE is largely a working-class service. And through its ESOL tradition and beyond it provides hope for people who have sought refuge on our shores. Euro2020 can teach us two things. Firstly, it’s on us to take up the social justice work of the England football team, even when we stumble and slip, miss a penalty or a trick. Living our values means addressing those systems, structures and processes that maintain the status quo of inequality. Not easy work, but if we can’t do it, then who will? Equality is a consistent, active practice. Secondly, we are all Gareth Southgate, expected to be outstanding all the time. This culture of perfectionism harms us all. Like him, we need to be allowed to take risks and make mistakes. And work, intentionally, where identities cross. The Thinkpiece returns next issue with a refreshed focus on Ideas Rooms. If you’ve experienced the joy that is the Ideas Room, please let us know how it worked out for your idea.
well-being
By SUSANNA BRANDON
Mindful Crossword
by Dr lou mycroft
The Future of Education... scholarship
Stop... Please don’t skip over this article because it has a word in the title that feels like it’s not for you. There’s a reason for that. I don’t warm to it either. It has connotations of academia, dusty books, ‘higher’ level study and - for a working class-woman - conjures up images of the Oxbridge tutorial rooms I saw on television as a bright kid, that were inaccessible to me. Old words replicate old ideas and it’s not enough to believe - as I do - that every single person reading this can be a ‘scholar’. The word itself seems insurmountable. But we are all thinkers and we all have the potential to articulate our thoughts. And we have so many avenues open to us now. This past year, FE has been on fire with educator-led podcasts, articles, blogs, animations, talks, videos and even radio stations. Plus wonderful spaces to explore your thinking with support from others, from the JoyFE Ideas Rooms through collaborative writing spaces like the Oasis to the new Research College Group? There’s almost too much (no, not really), so if you’ve got that pesky impostor sitting on your shoulder it’s all too easy to imagine no-one wants to hear what you’ve got to say. Using the word ‘scholarship’ layers on another barrier of self-doubt. Yet it’s out there, so maybe this is time to encounter it, to own it. We shouldn’t let our voice be silenced by a word, right? We here at the #JoyFE mag (don’t want to sound needy but WRITE FOR US) - and all those other places - welcome you with open arms. The very best spaces enable us to encounter one another across divides of thinking, experience, identity and culture. After all, we need new ideas to inspire our own thinking, or we’ll keep trundling around the same track. Humans feel safe in spaces where we encounter ‘like minded people’ but the danger is we end up in one big filter bubble, all saying the same words in slightly different ways. Scholarship is what lifts us out of this because we deliberately encounter new thinkers, whether that’s in a book or a TED talk or an online space. The process of coming to see even a long dead philosopher as a thinker rather than a theorist, a fellow traveller whose words are just more public than ours, is a powerful one. (Tip: calling them by their first name helps). Let’s shake the dust off that long-established word, scholarship. As thinkers, it’s other thinkers, combined with our own observations, thoughts and feelings, values and assumptions, who help shape our thinking. The process of coming to articulate our thoughts in public is refreshed by other writings and listenings that provoke and inspire. If we only read and listen to stuff we agree with, the best we can hope for is a new angle. #JoyFE is all about doing new things, not doing the same thing differently. I’ve spent the last few years engaging with others’ thinking in the hope that it might encourage me to think differently about my own certainties. It’s been uncomfortable work, but so much is shifting for me. Following thinkers on social media such as anti-racist activist Liz Pemberton and anti-ableism activist Mole Chapman - both powerful, witty, intelligent women I’m honoured to count as friends - has pushed me out of my comfort zone into unprecedented levels of self awareness and given me the chance - at last - to start writing stuff which is remarkable, rather than a rehashing of positions I’ve held for years. I’ve finally started to step outside my lane, developing a new and more challenging professional activism based on what I’m good at and what the world needs. Our #JoyFE summer reading challenge to you is to step outside your own lane and read something that you wouldn’t normally pick up. Share your thinking on social media using the hashtag #JoyfulRead21 Here’s a few of mine…what’s yours? Radical Candour by Kim Scott (literally transforming my relationships) The Values Economy by Alan and Sam Williams (fighting past some business-speak to get to the essence) The Power of Giving Away Power by Matthew Barzun (same) What White People Can Do Next by Emma Dabiri (laugh out loud, also refocusing me on ‘the work’) Black, Listed by Jeffrey Boakye (if you read one, read this, it’s remarkable)
9
It’s the little things that count… Whilst many of us are preparing to return (or get used to) a new way of working, it is important to remember the little things that keep us smiling and feeling ‘the joy’ during each day. Daily ‘check ins’ with teams, random acts of kindness and thoughtful gestures are incredibly important when building and maintaining supportive and effective team working. The ‘JoyFE’ constellation has been amazing at this over the past 5 months; we have sent our own ‘snippets of joy’ to each other (see images). These small yet incredibly powerful postal gifts have shone bright lights during dark times. This highlights the importance of inclusion and building a unified working space where everyone feels recognised and appreciated. Taking this into your work space and life in general is highly rewarding and fills your ‘joy cups’ as Sandi and Chris Phoenix agree enhances adult wellbeing (Early Year Wellbeing Festival – Kathy Brodie., 2020). Why not give it a try, see how much joy you can bring to someone's life:)
Snippets of SUMMER J Y !
WooooooooooooooooooooooooooooHooooooooooooooooooooOOOOOOOO Sorry, just needed to get that out. I’m writing this on the afternoon of the day I break up for summer holidays and (big sigh) I need this :)) So what’s in Snippets this month? It’s (drumroll)..….. ‘Snippets Commandments’ (I know being a column writer has really gone to my head, but give a girl some slack). Now with a nod to my Brummy upbringing and my wonderful Black Country neighbours I’m going to doctor this diktat with ‘yaow’ instead of ‘you’ and this should be read in the best Black Country accent you can muster, so let’s go for it. Yaow...(come on now if you aren’t trying the accent in your head or aloud, I WILL know now I’ve taken on omniscient qualities) Yaow shalt REST - now I mean it, no sneaky peeking at those emails, get that out of office on sharpish mate and make sure you take some days off where the kids are still at the childminder/babysitter/otherparent/school/nursery (delete as appropriate). There needs to be some YAOW time (see what I did there?!) this holiday. Yaow shalt get bored, let your mind wander and embrace what enters into said mind. Take time to let your thoughts flow and see where that takes you Yaow (come on now bab) shalt not feel guilty for taking time off and spending quality time with yaowself, yaow family or friends. Yaow shalt show gratitude to the blessings that occur in your life and will release yaowself from past imperfections. Wow I’m really going for it, let’s lighten this…. Yaow shall do what makes you happy this summer, spend time outdoors, alone, with friends, do what you need and want. Yaow shall come back in September, oh no scrap that, the b£$%^&& have brought the dates back this year, AUGUST (don’t worry we’ll be raring to go boss), with a commitment to NO GOBACKERY (thank you @jenkteach) and ensure yours and others voices are heard. In reference to the fab work you’ve done reading this in your head/aloud in a Black Country accent, and if you’ve had a blast doing it, why not get yaowself over to a brilliant taste of the Black Country this summer on your staycation, the brilliant Black Country Museum: https://www.bclm.co.uk/. Other attractions from other parts of the country are permitted but make sure yaow attempt the local dialect and accent. I’m listening!
By isla flood
How did you start your journey in further education? Deborah: I enrolled on an Exercise to Music instructor course in Liverpool at the age of 19 and was asked by my tutor to return as a ‘course assistant.’ I then started to teach on part-time evening courses. I was lucky enough to have two really inspirational teachers to support me. One with amazing expertise in equality and diversity, the other with a really great reputation in the industry. I was really fortunate to have a great manager in my first college job. They were kind and trusting. I worked hard and they gave me freedom. They knew if I left early to pick up the kids, I would still do my work, and do it well. We got great results and the department had an amazing reputation in the sector. How did you go from being a teacher to being a consultant and inspector? Deborah: My EV at the time was an inspector and mentioned that they were looking for part-time inspectors. I applied, but didn’t think I would get through – at the age of 29 I was probably one of the youngest inspectors they had. I’d also been thinking about starting a PHD, a piece of work that would bring together my passions of health, education and kindness. I wanted to explore how we could become a healthy college and really look after the health of our staff and students. Interestingly, I got turned down twice for an Advanced Practitioner role. I was quite shocked, I knew what kind of teacher I was, I knew it was my calling. I wondered why they didn’t see me as worthy of the role. Then my lovely manager retired, a new manager started and everything changed. We were told what to teach and how we should teach. Teachers and students became unhappy. I reduced my hours and started to test out the possibility of consultancy. In the end, the whole team left together. The difference between the managers was kindness - one cared and one didn’t. So you left a full time job and went into consultancy, how did that feel? Deborah: I started helping others prepare for inspection. I thought I would be out of my depth, but I developed an approach that was based on kindness. I saw senior leaders’ vulnerability, saw the impact on them of the pressures with Ofsted. Staff also felt vulnerable and exposed when thinking about Ofsted. As an inspector, I got used to seeing teachers’ fearful faces How did you bring the concept of kindness into this work? Deborah: My key concept is that we should think about ourselves less and about others more. When people are struggling mentally, their fears tend to be ‘what will Ofsted think’. We need to support teachers to focus on learners. The mistake we make is in asking this then not supporting them to do so. We then wonder why they are upset or struggling. We don’t spend enough time getting to the root causes of why teachers are unhappy, why students and young people are so unhappy.
an interview with... Deborah Mcvey
a journey of kindness and love interview by Jackie rossa
Deborah McVey is the co-owner of CH1 Fitness and CH1 Fitness Academy, and the founder of ’Build Teachers Up!'
12
This is an interesting concept. What would you say to managers who want to support their staff in this way? Deborah: Stop and think. Recognise that people have a reason for their behaviour that is often linked to fear. Have a conversation with them about the issue. We tend to avoid the difficult conversations, and this means we don’t see their perspectives. At least if we have the conversation, we can find out what is happening before things build up. Questions like, how do you feel when that happens? The problem is we don’t ask the questions, we try to fix things. Managers often think it is their job to fix rather than to support and encourage. What made you decide to leave further education? Deborah: I have loved the work in FE. The difficulty for me is that, whilst my two passions are education and health, my own health has suffered in trying to support both. In the end I had to be kind to myself. If you are not kind to yourself, you won’t be able to have any impact on the world. Sometimes we are not kind to ourselves with exercise either, we punish our bodies. Pressure and conformity is a big thing. It is not right in education that young people are pressurised to conform to what we have always done. We need to help our young people to find kindness. My gym is a small place with just a few clients, but I have found my joy here. I am going to be starting an academy soon so I will still have that joy of education, just in a different way. I am more connected when my passions come together – health and education, and of course kindness. The fitness industry can be judgemental and superficial. I am going to work on a smaller scale where I can have more influence, and find joy in that. The joy in helping others who want to start out, and being kind to people.
a journey of kindness and love
As I am from a school background I was drawn to the title of this book. My thinking was quickly converted to, ’how could I model this in FE?‘ into the “Thinking College”. This book in essence is a model for improving the quality of teaching and learning in schools and therefore improving progress. But, there is so much more; imagine if every learning environment was filled with your favourite teacher, the one that inspired you, enthused you, helped you to generate your motivation? What about the greatest leader you have worked for? What if all of these were under one roof? Leading learning is about creating an environment where all members of the community see themselves as leaders who are empowered to make decisions. Atwal advocates a move towards continued professional development where learning is sustained over a period of time with additional facilitation in the classroom to ensure the impact is measured through learner achievement. Atwal’s engagement with Lave and Wenger’s (1991) work on communities of practice is insightful. He connects it to the Thinking School, where teachers work collaboratively to develop practice together. In the Thinking School teachers have a voice and drive their own learning. CPD is not done to them. Leaders provide expansive opportunities. The glue that binds everyone together is coaching, everyone is responsible for everyone’s professional development. This requires a learning focused leader who is curious and relentless about their own practice, reflective about decision making in light of new research and focused on children’s outcomes. Every decision is analysed in terms of impact on their learning; inclusive of personal, social, emotional and moral development. Childrens’ learning is a barometer to measure effectiveness. This authentic distributed leadership model is instrumental in allowing staff to develop as leaders. Thinking teachers influence children’s thinking, leading to creative thinking and individual learning. Atwal’s own doctoral research investigated teacher engagement in action research as part of the organisation’s culture. Motivating teachers to research is covered in this book. What gets me every time I pick this book up is how it puts “fire in my belly”, seeking comfort from the constant emphasis on values and doing the right thing for our children. I love the reflective questions at the end of each chapter. When I revisit the book, I find a new wonder, a new question, a new curiosity. The passion behind Atwal’s work is phenomenal. The Thinking College will come to fruition. This book continues to shine hope and joy in my life.
BY jane prince
THE Thinking School – Developing a dynamic learning community Dr Kulvarn Atwal
BY mole chapman @eqtraining
A few thoughts on a conversation that began with the topic of allyship and disability, but took us towards an understanding of ableism as a priority yet to grasp in education. I define ableism and anti-ableism as: Ableism: a specific type of oppression, akin to homophobia, racism, classism, and sexism, held in the culture and language that inform society’s debates. Anti-ableist: a defined position against ableism, the characteristic oppression that disabled people face – akin to feminist or anti-racist. For three decades I’ve worked in FE. I began by sharing my bad experiences as a disabled learner within a system I could not fit. I often got the feeling that people didn’t believe me, or they assumed the attitudes I faced were isolated incidents of poor practice. Years went by and I started reading more and more accounts of disabled learners feeling equally at odds with working practice. Clearly there was an institutional expectation on learners to keep up and adapt, even when it cost them in terms of success. As time went by evidence of this pressure has mounted, as disabled authors sought to influence our understanding of disability, our language regarding learning, and the ableism within our spaces. Why have these writers not been believed either? Over the last three decades the prejudice, the systematic barriers and the institutional discrimination disabled learners face have remained unarticulated with regard to disability specifically. Ableism, like sexism and racism, has morphed, influenced by the reach for prestige within academia. I can’t help wondering if learners harmed by yesterday’s culture had been trusted, and practice and planning had altered, the space we now share would have changed? I’m angry at a total lack of movement. No, transformation hasn’t taken place. We need to do better as teachers. It’s as if we’re still aiming towards yesteryear’s legacy, not tomorrow’s more equitable imaginary. Sadly, the situation facing nearly 2 in 10 learners is difficult, painful and insidiously demeaning. We haven’t begun to talk about this, even the issue of performative action seems risible here, given the chasm needing exploration! I feel more equity is needed, an acknowledgement of the characteristic shape of ableism. While issues of sexism, racism, classism and homophobia are gaining recognition [in places], ableism rarely gets a look in. Where ableism is on the list, that’s where it stays! Crip theory is rarely fully developed in discussions written by those considering other protected characteristics. Rather than explore the full depth of the challenges ableism presents, many have reduced its meaning to a few arbitrary points - If they suit their narrative. Beyond the discipline, Disability Studies is domesticated, if considered in the first place. In terms of intersectionality there’s a dead-end where a cross-roads could lead to new horizons. As Ableism in Academia makes clear, education needs to be ‘… a safe space to explore and theorise what it means to be ‘othered’ and ‘different’ in an environment which is usually seen as privileged, yet where many feel they can’t express their needs’ (Brown, N. and Leigh, J. (eds) 2020, p.4). We still have little language to articulate ableism, let alone do justice to its toxic and all-pervasive nature. I’d say the larger number of educators I meet haven’t considered how ableist schooling is, while leadership texts abound without reference to ableism as barriers to participation - a human right. Addressing ableism is urgently needed, because it marginalisation is cumulative, it affects many of those who also face racism, homophobia, sexism, classism, ageism, sexual harassment, religious intolerance... as a protected characteristic ableism needs defining as a minimum, in a culture where Intersectionality is understood as going beyond the discrimination of nine characteristics: age, disability, gender reassignment, marriage and civil partnership, pregnancy and maternity, race, religion or belief, sex, and sexual orientation. Bibliography Brown, & Leigh. (2018). Ableism in Academia: where are the disabled and ill academics? Disability & Society, 33(6), 985-989. Brown, N. and Leigh, J. (eds) 2020. Ableism in Academia: Theorising experiences of disabilities and chronic illnesses in higher education. London: UCL Press. DOI: https://doi.org/10.14324/111.9781787354975 https://discovery.ucl.ac.uk/id/eprint/10110703/1/Ableism-in-Academia.pdf
is the space safe?
ARTICLE
15
Go on a shell or stone hunt. Collect stones you can paint or shells you can create a picture with
Go forest bathing
Find new walks in your local area
Contact your local canoe or rowing club for their next open days
Write letters or postcards. Send small gifts in the post
Celebrate yourself Treat yourself to something you have wanted for a while
Do joyful crafts - with air dry clay or things collected on nature walks
Visit museums and find your doppelganger in a gallery painting
Make a vision board What do you want your next 12 months to look like?
Click on each icon for more inspiration
Go wild swimming in a lake or river near you
17
During lockdown I took a daily walk. It was isolated and peaceful and gave me the chance to contemplate. The path was at the back of some houses and on the opposite side was woodland, which was overgrown with bracken, brambles and ivy. During the first lockdown I noticed one of the houses had rearranged the plot outside of their gate and planted some hydrangeas. I was pleased because hydrangeas are my favourite flowers, but also bemused that someone wanted to have an immaculate landscape amongst the dense and wild overgrowth opposite. What happened next really piqued my interest and I became obsessed with investigating this path. During each walk I noticed more homes had planted flowers, shrubs and small bushes on the land beyond their garden. I thought it was peculiar, the way that this chain reaction occurred, but it made the walk interesting, and the juxtaposition of the wilderness conflicted against the pristine landscaped plots and filled me with happiness. I noticed the two worlds began to collide, amongst the branches and ferns I saw a lone hydrangea plant and wondered how it moved from the landscaped side of the path to the wilderness side. I discovered that hydrangea plants are fascinating. The colour of the hydrangea flower is determined by the soil pH, adding aluminium to the soil of a pink hydrangea will transform it to a dramatic blue. The hydrangea itself is not one flower, but lots of small buds grouped together to form a single bloom, and beneath the ground is an undergrowth of rhizomes. These provide a rootlike system that slowly elongate and sprout, eventually breaking through the soil and forming a new stem, which is what happened here. On one walk I was contemplating staff training activities when the wonders of nature got me thinking, what if the magnificent hydrangea could be applied to the context of staff development? These thoughts led to more questions of a re-imagined staff development model. Staff development is the land beyond our garden, often left to wither and wilt and where individuals begrudgingly participate in something that they already know or have done a thousand times before, or it has little or no relevance to them because the training takes a one-size-fits-all approach. Like the hydrangea flower, educators are not a single entity but a collective, working together to form a cohesive community of practice. What if staff development could take on as much importance as the rest of the garden with a focus on the community plot, where everyone can blossom and grow? It only takes one person to make a change. It was one person who straightened the land beyond their garden and inspired others to follow suit. We must acknowledge that if we want outcomes to be different then we must change. If the hydrangea sits in the same soil, it will forever flower the same colour, if we want to alter the blossom colour then the soil needs to be adjusted. This got me thinking about the foundations of staff development, if we always take the same approach, we will always get the same outcomes, and perhaps one-size-fits-all is not the best method for genuinely engaging and impactful development. What if staff development embeds an approach that takes account of individual contexts? The rhizomes of the hydrangea sprout new shoots which break through the soil, proudly emerging as a new shrub. Perhaps CPD might take on a rhizomatic approach where participants learn with and from each other, sprouting new thoughts and ideas through acknowledging their own context, creating a network of ideas to progress and develop where something new emerges at the end. What if staff development encouraged authentic contextualised growth that was interconnected, garnered critical thinking, and fuelled personalised learning? I don’t have the answers to these questions, but what I have concluded is that we are not pot bound, we can modify the foundations, we are agents of change and have the power to shake things up. The beautiful hydrangea has revolutionised how I think. It has taught me that digging deeper can reveal new ways of thinking and understanding, not just within the garden, but the educational landscape and beyond.
the hydrangea effect
BY laura rawson
18
This poem was inspired by a conversation with Saj Mohammad.
Feature: POEM
Flower Arranging
By Elizabeth Draper @draperel
There is a love to be found, In an arrangement of flowers. All kinds. Think about it. A wave of delphinium and A crush of cornflowers and Blackthorn blossom piercing through A springtime dance of daffodils. A deep burst of blue Gentian Violets. The promise of apple blossom Joining the tricolour comfort of heartsease, tickle -my -fancy Blues, pinks, dark purples, yellows: spectacular in a jug. A nostalgia of thistles, harebells, heather. The garden orange flare of montbretia. Red field poppies. A reminder.
Flower Knowledge Flower Education Life changing discoveries found In the familiar of flowers. Bluebells. Remember the pleasure -domes brought The precious love-sent messages The ideas. By way of example This community arranging of flowers. Community education never underestimates Possibilities, Needs out there. To be met. Do not forget.
19
BY PETER LEYLAND @peterleyland12
The end of face-to-face teaching might have meant the end of our WEA poetry reading classes except for three indefatigable students of mine who wanted to carry on with it on Zoom. We have been gathering together most weeks and the class is due to restart in July. Reading and listening to poetry aloud is good for us, for our health, for our wellbeing, for our sense of sharing and caring. Nick Collins, Science Correspondent for The Telegraph, reports that researchers from Essex University found that poetry had a special effect on the brain where introspective thoughts are processed. Reading it, he says, affects parts of the brain linked to memories and feelings. Over the lockdown the group read poems by Charles Causley, Mary Oliver, Keith Douglas, Caroline Bird, and Owen Sheers. Choices were random but then we started working back through poets-laureate starting with Simon Armitage. We reached John Betjeman and through reading and discussion I began to have a better appreciation of his work. His poem Norfolk about lost innocence and set in the Broads, recalled for me a visit I took there on a houseboat with my daughter. Other highlights in my students’ words are Charles Causley’s Eden Rock: ‘This poem…is written as he approaches his own death. The picture of his parents welcoming him to the stage that he is entering is wonderfully painted.’ And this about I Happened to be Standing by Mary Oliver: ‘During the past twelve months, much of the time in Lockdown, I’m sure many of us have spent time standing by an open-door musing on what we can see – Then a wren in the privet began to sing. He was positively drenched in enthusiasm… Drenched is such a powerful evocative word.’ Or this: ‘Pauline Stainer is a poet I have liked for a long time. Her poems are beautiful, lyrical, strange, positive. From Ferry - Did the shore-line alter with the dawn as we sculled to the sandstone pagoda? Memory still throws its quoit of polished steel over that crossing by water…’ Some years ago, I taught poetry reading to prisoners. One responded with his own which I managed to have published in a poetry magazine. This is from And Rumours of War and is about the feelings of isolation of the prisoner, CHES N G’TAH, as he waited for his time to pass: ‘Bars protect me from the threat of swallows; Walls guard me from the danger of primroses; strong doors shield me from the perils of the west wind…’ His poem threw ‘its quoit of polished steel’, over my memory of him.
20
READING POETRY
21
By Jackie Rossa
Dear Jackie
Dear Jackie, I have been reading a lot in the news about the problem of students’ ‘lost’ or ‘missed’ learning due to Covid. We have also been told by our managers that we will be expected to plan to ‘fill’ these gaps – but we have no extra time with the learners to do this. Please help, I really want our learners to succeed, but have no idea how to go about this. Dear Jackie says As you say, there is a lot of understandable anxiety about these gaps in learning that may have been created as a result of Covid. The extent and nature of these gaps will, of course, vary from learner to learner, and a huge range of factors will have impacted on this. Whilst this might initially seem problematic, it does present us with a wonderful opportunity to carry out a rigorous, holistic evaluation of our learners’ start points in relation to their goals, dreams and ambitions. Too often we take learners’ grades/qualifications as an accurate indication of their current status, yet this assumption is frequently wrong. So now, we find ourselves in a position where we KNOW that we don’t know. We cannot rely on the grades or qualification that learners come in with, so we need to make our own decisions about their start points. Quite simply, the only gap that you need to focus on is the gap between where they are now and where they want to be, and to plan how you and the learner will work together to close it. This means you need to carry out a really good analysis of their start points. This includes everything – their current skills and knowledge, academic, personal and practical, their attitudes and mind-set towards learning, their emotional and physical health, levels of motivation and commitment, hope and optimism etc. Let’s not forget their digital skills and access to online learning – just in case. By doing this, and identifying the gap (that always existed even before Covid) between where they are and where they want to be, you will be able to work with them to identify the things they need to do to succeed, flourish and thrive. Dark Jackie says: This can easily be achieved as a great induction activity – for example ‘find your missing learning’ could be a kind of ‘Where’s Wally’ affair with posters on the wall or a treasure hunt, with bits of learning hidden in college corridors or toilets. You might want to try hiding them in places learners frequently avoid like the library, careers advice centre or smoking shelters. An extension activity might be a really neat ‘find the missing teacher’ task. This can be a good way of covering lessons for staff who are isolating after getting ‘pinged’ yet again by the app.
Want more joy delivered to your Inbox? Click here to receive #JoyFE magazine direct.
contributors
Team: @jackierossa_ @stef_wilkinson @katheryncocker1 @heatherbmartin @islaflood @loumycroft @SusannaBrandon @greavesmichaela
Want to be part of the #JoyFE conversation? Join our #JoyFE Facebook group AND Join us on Zoom for the #IdeasRoom on Wednesday evenings at 8pm (term time on Friday mornings at 9am) using the Thinking Environment to explore ideas (DM @JoyfulFE for the password). OR Why not write an article ? Submissions always welcome EMAIL: joyfulfe@gmail.com
Guests: @leadwithaheartx @peterleyland12 @_daniel_scott @EQTraining Laura Rawson @StephanieCowli3 Salma Younis Erin Marshall @Erin_F_Marshall @draperel
23